Daughters
of the Dust
Scene Analysis
[1] This essay will provide a close reading
of the scene in which Nana Peazant creates a syncretism of her traditional
African magic and the "modern" Christian philosophy with which her family
will be bombarded upon crossing over to the mainland. By creating
a charm using Yellow Mary's St. Christopher medal and other objects from
her tin can and affixing it to Viola's Bible, she creates a charm that
contains elements of both the family's traditional African background and
its future Christian American one that is intended to protect them and
tie them to her despite their soon-to-come separation. This scene
is significant to the plot for many reasons, the greatest being its demonstration
of the fact that the traditional African folkways can be melded with changing
American ones. It also is important because it promotes part of the
Afrocentric philosophy put forward in the film about community and family.
Persons who were not necessarily born into the Peazant family are nevertheless
accepted into it when they profess a commitment to the family's values.
Finally,
it shows that this amalgamation is not harmful to either
culture; the Christian does not suffer from the influence of the African,
or vice versa.
[2] Throughout the film, Nana has been
charging her family not to forget about their past, while some of the other
Peazants (headed up by Haagar) have been criticizing
Nana for refusing to accept the present or look towards the future.
Repeated references to Nana's "old tin can" are often made with a derogatory
tone, indicating that many of the Peazants have lost their faith in the
old ways which Nana still practices. Haagar is at the forefront of
this criticism of Nana's ways, and openly expresses her distaste for them.
During this climactic scene, Haagar cries out against what Nana has done,
calling it a "hoodoo mess" and denouncing her
relatives for their participation in an act of sacrilege. Once again
she rejects the old ways, insisting that none of the old traditions are
going to change anything now; despite Nana's pleas, Haagar turns and walks
away from the ceremony, effectively alienating herself from the rest of
the family. She even becomes distanced from her own daughters, who
remain behind to take part in the ritual, and from one of whom she will
ultimately be separated forever when the next morning arrives.
[3] The scene nevertheless ends on an uplifting
note, with Viola's struggle with and final acceptance of Nana's charm.
Because of her devout Christianity, Viola was the first Peazant to become
upset when Nana incorporated the Bible into her root working. As
Nana begins to offer her charm to the family to be kissed and accepted,
Viola becomes hysterical; she feels as though she should, as a good Christian,
reject these "heathen" ways. But having watched Haagar's near-violent
reaction and resulting denouncement of her family, and being moved by Mr.
Snead's desire to accept and be accepted by the Peazant clan, she realizes
that there is nothing sinful in what Nana has done. Discovering that
what Nana has been preaching bears such a similarity to her own Christian
beliefs - love for the family and honor for its past - she is able to reconcile
the two in her heart and finally participate in the ritual Nana has created.
[4] Mr. Snead and Eula's participation
in the ceremony are also significant to conveying Nana's message.
Although these two were not born into the Peazant family - Eula married
Eli Peazant, and Mr. Snead has never even met the Peazants until today
- their willingness to embrace the family's traditions and to love its
members for their connection to the Peazant family history makes it very
simple for them to gain acceptance into that circle. It seems that
the Peazants have an ability to provoke the desire to learn more about
traditional African folk-ways in willing students; Eula, who is not a Peazant
by birth, nevertheless sees much of herself in Nana and embraces her as
her own great-grandmother. Mr. Snead also is moved by his brief meeting
with the Peazants to delve more into the history of the Sea Island Negroes;
by this scene he has been so altered and uplifted by his learning that
his desire to become part of the Peazant family has overcome his mainland
Christian propriety; he kisses Viola with what seems to be abandon in comparison
with all his earlier logical and scientific behavior.
[5] Nana's use of the Bible in creating
a charm for her departing family disproves Haagar's claim that she is too
firmly rooted in the past, and demonstrates that Nana is capable of changing
with the times. Furthermore, it shows that to juxtapose the Christian
and the traditional African does not lessen the impact or the meaning of
either. The African, represented by Nana, clearly feels no animosity
towards the Christian; Nana's use of the Bible in her root working demonstrates
her willingness to incorporate the teachings and philosophy of Christianity
into her ways. Furthermore, Mr. Snead's passionate embracing of the
Peazants' ways accompanied by Viola's acquiescence shows that it is possible
to celebrate one's ancestral past and still be a good Christian.
[6] The construction of this scene is careful
and delicate; the filmmakers obviously attempted to balance the intense
emotional content of the scene by using subdued lighting and sound.
There is no musical accompaniment to this scene as there is for many others.
The ritual where Nana offers her charm-Bible to the family takes place
in low, murmuring tones, sounds which are soothing and endearing in comparison
to Viola's hysteria and Haagar's harsh, angry outburst. The camera
angles change, but only offer different perspectives on family members
as they cry together, embrace each other, and celebrate their love for
one another. The only characters who stand alone in any shot are
Haagar and Trula as they refuse to participate in the ritual and flee the
scene.
Copyright (c) 2001 by Heather Sullivan, Undergraduate
at The College of New Jersey.